When I read an article about empathic rupture by Dr Psych Mom, I was intrigued.

I thought back in time during my life when I’ve experienced this from other people.

Oddly, the first thought I had was not with my husband, (I’ll get to that in a minute,) but an incident with my GP doctor, which highlights the fact that you don’t have to be married to someone to experience this. It can happen in any relationship.

I’d been seeing my GP Doctor for years. The last time, was for a variety of health issues, but the one burning issue (and I DO mean burning) was when I had intense itching in a spot with no redness or signs of irritation. That is, until I started scratching it. I’d scratch it to the point of bleeding.

Never had anything like it before, or since.

He must have been in a real pissy mood that day.

When I explained the issue, and how intense it was, he said in a flippant, dismissive way “how about try not scratching it??”

What the bloody hell?

I felt like telling him “What if you had bugs crawling on your d!ck?? Should someone tell YOU not to scratch it?”

Needless to say, that was my last visit with him, and I got myself a woman doctor instead. I get that doctors have bad days too, but sheesh, that was uncalled-for. His narcissistic-like empathy deficit effectively ruined our doctor-patient relationship.

By the way, I never did get any help from him with my issue. It was as if I’d never said anything at all. That’s an empathic rupture outside an intimate relationship.

The Empathic Rupture in My Marriage (and this was a doozy)

I was 9 months pregnant with our second child, my daughter. I was home alone with my son, who was around 9 months old, when my water broke. My contractions were about twenty minutes apart then.

Husband was at my dad’s place, one town over, 20 minutes away, drinking beer. I called and told him the news, thinking he’d come home quickly, since you know, I was having our baby?

I waited.

He didn’t show.

I called again.

By now my contractions were 5 minutes apart.

I called my mom, desperate to get someone over to watch our 9 month old son. I was panicking, crying, and on my knees by the time my husband came home.

I didn’t want to have my daughter on our bedroom floor. I could hardly walk by the time he got home. I was in so much pain and I was scared. To make matters worse, we got to the hospital, and the front door was locked. I dropped to my knees again, now screaming. Luckily a security guard saw me and hurried over with a wheelchair. I had my daughter 20 minutes later. It would have been sooner, had I not been so scared. I was petrified of the pain without epidural like I had with my son.

I won’t get into how resentful this has made me over the years. The way he put me, and our daughter’s lives in possible peril, just so he could keep drinking with my dad. A night he has likely long forgotten. For what? The damage this empathic rupture did to our relationship is incalculable.

I couldn’t see him in the same light after that, despite the fact that he’d done some pretty nasty, and unloving things to me in the past, that honestly, any sane woman would have left before then.

I never came right out and told him how I felt about this. Not even when I told him I wanted a divorce. The hurt at his outright disregard for our safety is more than I care to dredge up again.

What’s the use?

For me, this was the ultimate empathic rupture, because I never truly forgave him. When I think about it years later, it still makes me sad, infuriatied, and blown away that he’d do something so careless, and stupid, during such an important and critical event.

I’ve carried it since 2002. I should have brought this up immediately, but I now had a toddler and an infant, and needed to put my focus on them. I was committed to it. I was also terrified of leaving.

What is an Empathic Rupture?

The term “empathic rupture” isn’t commonly found in standard dictionaries, but it can be understood by breaking down the two words:

1. Empathic: Pertaining to empathy, which is the ability to understand and share the feelings of another.
2. Rupture: A break or breach in something, often referring to a significant disruption or disturbance.

Combining these, an “empathic rupture” refers to a significant break or disruption in the empathetic connection between people. This can occur when one person feels misunderstood, invalidated, or emotionally disconnected from another, leading to resentment, a breakdown in communication, and mutual understanding.

In therapeutic or relational contexts, it describes a moment where the bond of empathy is fractured, potentially causing emotional distress or conflict.

An empathic rupture occurs when there is a breakdown in the emotional connection and understanding between two people, often due to a failure to empathize with one another’s feelings, needs, or experiences.

This can happen in any relationship, including romantic partnerships, friendships, or even therapeutic relationships.

Key Aspects of an Empathic Rupture:

1. Loss of Emotional Connection:

The affected individual feels misunderstood, ignored, or invalidated, leading to emotional distance and disconnection.

2. Failure to Acknowledge Feelings:

When one person fails to recognize or validate the other’s emotions, it can cause hurt and frustration.

3. Miscommunication:

Misunderstandings or misinterpretations during communication can lead to an empathic rupture, as one or both parties feel their feelings are not being accurately perceived or respected.

4. Breach of Trust:

Trust is eroded when one person feels that their emotional needs are not being met or respected, leading to a breakdown in the relationship.

5. Emotional Withdrawal:

The person who feels the rupture may withdraw emotionally, avoiding further vulnerability to protect themselves from additional hurt.

When do Empathic Ruptures Usually Happen?

Empathic ruptures can happen in various contexts and at different times, but they often occur in situations where emotional sensitivity and understanding are important.

Here are some common scenarios when empathic ruptures are likely to happen:

1. High-Stress Situations:

Example: During a crisis or high-pressure moment, individuals might lack the emotional bandwidth to be empathetic, leading to dismissive or insensitive responses.

2. Conflict and Disagreements:

Example: During arguments or conflicts, emotions run high, and people may say hurtful things or fail to understand the other person’s perspective, causing a rupture.

3. Moments of Vulnerability:

Example: When someone shares a deeply personal or vulnerable experience and the other person responds insensitively or dismissively, it can cause significant emotional hurt.

4. Routine Interactions:

Example: Everyday conversations where one partner or friend is consistently inattentive, distracted, or dismissive can lead to a build-up of small ruptures over time.

5. Major Life Changes:

Example: During significant life events such as moving, job loss, or the birth of a child, stress levels can be high, and the need for empathy increases. Failure to provide this support can lead to ruptures.

6. Unmet Expectations:

Example: When one person has expectations for emotional support or understanding that are not met, it can create feelings of disappointment and disconnect.

7. Emotional Burnout:

Example: Caregivers or partners who are emotionally exhausted might struggle to provide empathy, leading to ruptures in their relationships.

8. Cultural or Value Clashes:

Example: Differences in cultural backgrounds or personal values can lead to misunderstandings and a lack of empathy, causing ruptures.

9. Lack of Communication Skills:

Example: Poor communication skills, such as not listening actively or interrupting, can lead to feelings of being unheard and misunderstood.

10. Mental Health Issues:

Example: Conditions like depression, anxiety, or personality disorders can impair one’s ability to empathize, leading to frequent ruptures.

11. Routine Neglect:

Example: Over time, neglecting to check in emotionally or show appreciation can lead to feelings of being taken for granted, thus causing ruptures.

12. Power Imbalances:

Example: In relationships with significant power imbalances, the more dominant person may fail to empathize with the other’s perspective, leading to disconnection.

Empathic ruptures usually happen when one person’s emotional needs are not met or acknowledged by the other, resulting in feelings of hurt, disappointment, and disconnection.

Have you noticed any specific situations where empathic ruptures tend to happen in your relationships?

Examples of Empathic Rupture in Relationships

Empathic ruptures can occur in various contexts and relationships. Here are some real-life examples to illustrate how they might manifest:

1. Romantic Relationship:

Scenario: One partner dismisses the other’s feelings about a stressful day at work by saying, “You’re overreacting; it’s not that big of a deal.”

Impact: The dismissed partner feels invalidated and misunderstood, leading to emotional distance and hurt.

2. Parent-Child Relationship:

Scenario: A teenager expresses anxiety about an upcoming exam, and the parent responds with, “Just try harder and stop worrying so much.”

Impact: The teenager feels unsupported and unheard, resulting in a breakdown of trust and communication.

3. Friendship:

Scenario: A friend shares their excitement about a personal achievement, but the other friend quickly changes the subject to talk about their own problems.

Impact: The first friend feels overlooked and undervalued, leading to feelings of neglect and emotional withdrawal.

4. Workplace:

Scenario: An employee voices concerns about an unfair workload, and the manager responds with, “Everyone is busy; you need to deal with it.”

Impact: The employee feels unappreciated and unsupported, which can lead to disengagement and decreased morale.

5. Therapeutic Setting:

Scenario: A client shares a traumatic experience, and the therapist responds with a clinical, detached comment like, “That sounds challenging.”

Impact: The client feels misunderstood and may lose trust in the therapist, hindering the therapeutic process.

6. Marriage:

Scenario: One spouse expresses feelings of loneliness, and the other spouse dismisses it by saying, “You have nothing to be lonely about; I’m here, aren’t I?”

Impact: The lonely spouse feels invalidated, leading to increased emotional distance and potential resentment.

7. Social Gathering:

Scenario: During a group conversation, one person shares a personal story, and another interrupts with a joke that downplays the seriousness of the story.

Impact: The storyteller feels disrespected and hurt, potentially pulling back from the group emotionally.

8. Sibling Relationship:

Scenario: One sibling confides in another about feeling left out in family gatherings, and the other sibling responds with, “You’re just being too sensitive.”

Impact: The confiding sibling feels dismissed and unsupported, which can strain the sibling bond.

9. Healthcare Setting:

Scenario: A patient expresses fear about a medical procedure, and the doctor responds with, “You don’t need to worry; it’s a routine procedure.”

Impact: The patient feels their anxiety is not taken seriously, leading to a loss of trust in the healthcare provider.

10. School Environment:

Scenario: A student tells their teacher about being bullied, and the teacher responds with, “Just ignore them; they’ll stop eventually.”

Impact: The student feels unsupported and might feel unsafe, leading to increased anxiety and disengagement from school.

These examples highlight how an empathic rupture can occur through dismissive, insensitive, or self-centered responses. Addressing these ruptures involves acknowledging the hurt caused, expressing genuine empathy, and working to rebuild the emotional connection.

Causes of Empathic Ruptures

Insensitive Comments:

Offhand remarks that dismiss or belittle someone’s feelings.

Lack of Attention:

Failing to listen attentively or show concern.

Self-Centered Behavior:

Prioritizing one’s own needs and emotions while neglecting the other’s.

Unresolved Conflicts:

Ongoing issues that are not properly addressed can lead to repeated ruptures.

High-Stress Situations:

Stress can reduce one’s capacity to empathize, leading to misunderstandings.

Restoring an Empathic Rupture

1. Acknowledge the Rupture:

Recognize and admit that a breakdown in empathy has occurred.

2. Open Communication:

Have an honest conversation about what happened, how it made both parties feel, and the impact on the relationship.

3. Express Empathy:

Make a genuine effort to understand and validate the other person’s feelings.

4. Apologize Sincerely:

Offer a heartfelt apology if you contributed to the rupture, acknowledging the hurt caused.

5. Seek Resolution:

Work together to find a way to prevent similar ruptures in the future, which might involve setting new communication strategies or boundaries.

6. Rebuild Trust:

Gradually rebuild trust through consistent, empathetic behavior and open dialogue.

Understanding and addressing empathic ruptures can help restore and strengthen emotional connections, making relationships more resilient. When we actively work to repair these breaks in empathy, we not only mend the immediate damage but also build a stronger foundation of trust and understanding.

This proactive approach creates deeper, more resilient relationships that can withstand future challenges. By valuing and nurturing our emotional bonds, we ensure that our connections remain healthy, supportive, and enduring.

Have you experienced an empathic rupture in any of your relationships, and how did you handle it?